The old new way of conducting counterinsurgency

Comments

[this is good]
Nice post. I've always loved Marines.
[this is good]
I'm glad to know you all are doing so well, and by the faces in these pictures I see the people of Fallujah like you there as well.

Do you all need anything that we from the states can send you? Is there any needs that you would like us to send for the Iraqi's you are living amongst?

Thank you guys for all you are doing. I look forward to reading these books that these warriors will write.
The Thunder Run has linked to this post in the - <a href="http://thunderrun.blogspot.com/2007/11/web-reconnaissance-for-11082007.html"> Web Reconnaissance for 11/08/2007 </a> A short recon of what’s out there that might draw your attention, updated throughout the day...so check back often.
[this is good]
We are glad to hear things are improving!!
[this is good]

What a wonderful article, and what great pictures! I love seeing how the people are smiling, going on about their business - working, playing and just living - without fear because you are there to help and protect them. I swell with pride and relief to see this. You guys are doing an absolutely superlative job, and I will do what I can to make more people aware of it. This good news needs to be spread far and wide - especially to the halls of Pelosi, Reid, etc.

Sorry this is so long, but here's one final thought: you might consider signing up with anysoldier.com and asking for things that you need or would really like to have - such as laundry detergent! Maybe someone back at the FOB could do that for you and you could arrange to have things brought out to you. That way, not only could you provide links to your blog and spread the news about the great things you're doing, but you could also request some help from us regular folks in the US (and other countries) who appreciate and support you and want to help.

[this is good]
thinking of y'all today - thanks for doing what you do. take care, keep up the good work, and come home soon!

As far as a Marine living out of a bucket, I got issued a bucket and scrub brush in boot camp and learned the many many uses of these tiems. There was a stool, fire brigade bucket, laundry, and even a punishment tool, ( having to smoke the contraband cigs a Navy "friend" back home sent me..had to smoke them with my bucket over my head) and other uses. I'm thinking the new Marines are just as skilled in their use...and just as surprised to have to use those skills after boot camp as I was.

What a blast from the past about 3/5, I was in a spin off unit of 5th Marines, 5th Comm Bn, a larger comm pool to draw from, and it only existed 5 years and stood down in 1971. We had dealings with the CAP units in the AO's we operated in and I'm still in contact with some old CAPs. That complacency issue is a real one to deal with. Some CAPs that went back to Vietnam recently and visited with old village friends found out some were VC all along. So, some smiling Iraqi may still hold a grudge.

Another problem I see is solved by having the line unit be the de facto CAP unit At times, when a line unit( way different philosophy than the CAPs on rules of engagement at the time) or any other "strangers" approached a CAP vill, the suspicious mode was on until the CAPs felt there was no threat to their Village. Having the line unit as the CAP solves part of that problem. After we got permission from the CAPs to pass theorugh their vills, the trading began. We got their local intel, gossip, security tips and assistance in return for anything we could scrounge for them and their village...paint, scrap wood and metal, cooking fuel etc.. The program worked then and should now, given enough time.

Keep up the good works and don't blow out a knee in the "football" games.

[this is good]

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in