Tribal contributions to counterinsurgency

Comments

[this is good]
This is good. There was a comment on one of my posts on my blog that claimed there is "no civilian support" in Iraq. Good to see that eyes on the ground say otherwise.
[this is good]
Interesting and encouraging post. Clearly, getting the citizens to 'own' their own solution is the way to go. Keep up the good work!
[this is good]
glad such intelligent and sightful americans are there telling us the truth. keep up the good work! your writing is good.
[this is good]
This is very encouraging news indeed.
[this is good]
Hmm...here's a tough thing to consider.

On one hand, they are maintaining the peace, and hoping for a more peaceful future without such violence, for the sakes of their families.

On the other, the insurgents think that they are traitors to race and religion, that they are supporters of the Americans thus branding them as munafiqs, and that can't be good for them once Americans leave.
Aput

It's not like that. It doesn't matter if they're branded "munafiqs" or not, they are already fighting Al Qaeda to begin with. The terrorists are not in positions of power anymore. The sheiks have been enabled to take over authority of the region; that's the whole point. They have the dominant position now, not the terrorists.

It would be like you being branded a traitor to air travel. Meaningless and insiginificant.
True, they are fighting off Al Qaeda, which is but one side of the insurgency. There's also Muqtada al-Sadr, who has issued out a warning that anyone who supports the Americans are therefore munafiqs (apostates), and are therefore punishable by death.

They may not have problems in Al-Anbar, but it is still worrying to think of such edicts. It sounds just like someone else, who said "either you're with us or against us".
Aput,

No one denies Iraq is a complicated place. However, what we are trying to do is establish local forces capable of fighting off terrorists. To that end, we are greatly succeeding. And in that success we are forging a template for success in other parts of the country.

Like any organization, the sentiments in the Shia insurgency are not homogeneous. There are rifts and divides. There's a desire in most rational people for equilibrium. That is all we are trying to get done here in Anbar and in Iraq at large.

How did the killing of Allawi Al-Issawi and the subsequent suicide bombing of his funeral procession (I read in NY Times May 24) play out for your group? Much of the article was about Anbar Province and Fallujah. Naturally, I thought of all of you. It seems that some of the tribesman are in the Al Quada camp. Please take care of yourselves.

Buckeye, I am trying to get a comprehensive answer to your question now.
Buckeye, Marines from Regimental Combat Team 6 provided a Quick Reaction Force (QRF) to secure the area. The Fallujah Police Department and soldiers from the Iraqi Army responded quickly to the scene. The Iraqi Security Forces (ISF) assisted in transporting the wounded to a nearby medical facility for treatment.

The ISF took control of the scene and surrounding area as they now hold the security for the city. More or less, we are in a supporting role.

The incident, while tragic, proves that Al Qeada in Iraq targets civilians. This is one of the main reasons that the local populace is ready to take on more of a security role, therefore they volunteer to be policemen or Provincial Security Force (PSF) members.


Thank you. Yes, the NY Times article specifically stated that it seemed to be an attack on civilians. Are you going to have some links to the embedded journalists and bloggers whom you mentioned before were going to produce some material on your area?
[this is good]
I spent six weeks a Al Asad back in 2005, took a trip out near the border area. Things were different then, my Brother and Sister Marines seemed to be in a pretty good fight, one-sided as it was. It's good to hear the populace is coming around.
I met fellow contractor on the way out of Iraq who mentioned a high rate of conversion to Christianity, particularly among the women. I am by no means a religious man, and would rather see a more deist world than this widely split mess we have now (Muslim, Christian, Jew, etc). However, do you find that to still be the case with conversion rates?

Stay safe!

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in